† Corresponding author. E-mail:
Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. 11674404, 41330206, and 11374121).
We present a novel technique for controlling oxygen fugacity, which is broadly used to in-situ measure the electrical conductivities in minerals and rocks during diamond anvil cell experiments. The electrical conductivities of olivine are determined under controlled oxygen fugacity conditions (Mo–MoO2) at pressures up to 4.0 GPa and temperatures up to 873 K. The advantages of this new technique enable the measuring of the activation enthalpy, activation energy, and activation bulk volume in the Arrhenius relationship. This provides an improved understanding of the mechanism of conduction in olivine. Electrical conduction in olivine is best explained by small polaron movement, given the oxygen fugacity-dependent variations in conductivity.
In-situ laboratory determinations of the electrical conductivities of minerals and rocks at high pressures and temperatures are the most robust and simple way to investigate the compositions, natures, and states of minerals in Earth’s deep interior.[1,2] Such measurements are typically combined with magnetotelluric (MT) and geomagnetic deep sounding (GDS) to ascertain the mineral and chemical composition, thermodynamic state, presence, and distribution of water, and partial melting processes within the Earth.[3–10] Notably, the effect of oxygen fugacity on the electrical properties of a sample is far greater than those of temperature, pressure, and other factors in high temperature–pressure conductivity experiments.[11–13]
In conventional conductivity experiments, oxygen fugacity control can be achieved by manipulating the gas buffer proportions.[14] However, this method is only applicable to experimental devices at lower working pressures, such as piston cylinder presses.[15,16] Subsequently, a method of controlling oxygen fugacity with a solid oxygen buffer was used in high-pressure measurements. Xu et al.[17,18] proposed a new method of controlling the oxygen fugacity by using an Mo+MoO2 (MMO) solid buffer in a multi-anvil apparatus, and successfully determined the electrical conductivity of (high-pressure) olivine. More recently, Dai et al.[19–23] used various solid buffers (i.e., Fe3O4+Fe2O3, Ni+NiO, Fe+Fe3O4, Fe+FeO, Mo + MoO2) on a YJ-3000t multi-anvil press to determine the conductivity of lherzolite, peridotite, and polycrystalline and hydrous olivine under controlled oxygen fugacity condition. Although the use of sintered diamond as a secondary anvil can attain lower mantle pressure condition (∼ 80 GPa; ≤ 2000 K),[24,25] most multi-anvil apparatus are suitable for being used under condition of the upper mantle (∼ 28 GPa; ≤ 2500 K).[26] Hence, diamond anvil cells (DAC) are used to attain high pressures that reach core–mantle boundary conditions.[27] Furthermore, very high temperatures (≤ 4000 K) can be obtained with a DAC equipped with a laser heating system (LH-DAC). Combined with other experimental methods, the DAC set-up is used to mimic the temperature–pressure conditions of Earth’s interior and measure the physical properties of typical mantle minerals.[28–31]
However, conductivity testing with a DAC may introduce relatively large systematic errors as a result of the following three factors. (i) The sample chamber is only hundreds of microns in size and the oxygen fugacity control method used in conventional multi-anvil press experiments is not suitable. As such, previous DAC mineral conductivity experiments have rarely considered the effects of oxygen fugacity.[32,33] (ii) Uncertainties exist in the sample thickness. Deformation of diamond and sealing gaskets make it difficult to measure the thickness of the sample. (iii) Electrical conductivity in a DAC experiment is typically measured by placing a thin metal wire electrode in the sample chamber,[34] but the shape and position of the electrode wires cannot be fixed during pressure loading.
Given these limitations and inspired by the successful oxygen fugacity control in large-volume multi-anvil experiments, we have developed and presented a novel technique to control the oxygen fugacity in DAC experiments and conduct the completely accurate conductivity measurements. We use magnetron sputtering and thin-film micro processing technology to facilitate in situ oxygen fugacity control at high pressures and temperatures. Using this approach, we measure the conductivity of anhydrous olivine and compare the result with those previously measured. Our new technique is broadly applicable to conductivity measurements under high pressure andtemperature conditions of the deep Earth.
The olivine samples were obtained from the Damaping area of Hebei Province, China. The olivine was handpicked and then ground into powder in agate. Then, the powder samples were baked in a 393-K baking oven for 24 h to completely eliminate the adsorbed water in the whole assemblage. The chemical composition of the sample was determined by energy dispersive spectrometry (Fig.
The experiments under high pressures and temperatures were performed with the new DAC device as shown in Fig.
To fabricate the microcircuit on the diamond anvil, we adapted the Gao et al.’s method[35] A mixed film of Mo and MoO2 was sputtered on the face of the diamond anvil to form electrodes. The sputtering power was 90 W and the chamber working gas pressure was 1.0 Pa. The flow ratio of Ar to O2 was 1.6 : 30. The film was then integrated into a two-electrode configuration microcircuit through photolithography. After the preparation of the electrical circuit, an alumina layer (Al2O3) was deposited on the circuit. This acted as an electrical and heat insulator and surrounded the microcircuit. A detection window was made in the center of the culet by removing the covering alumina, which kept the film electrode contacting the sample. The anvil and electrode configuration are shown in Figs.
We developed a complex gasket, which is a metal gasket with an oxygen fugacity buffering ring and insulating gasket material as shown in Fig.
A Solartron-1260 impedance/gain-phase analyzer was used to record the impedance spectrum. This was operated with a signal voltage of 1 V at frequency ranging from 10−1 Hz to 107 Hz. Temperature was varied in steps of 50 K, with the electrical conductivity being measured at each step. For the sample thickness measurements it was assumed that the diamond deformation was elastic and so was it during loading and unloading. If the gasket undergoes entirely plastic deformation, then the thickness of the sample (t) at each pressure during compression is
where Lm is the sample thickness at maximum pressure and δP is the difference in thickness between loading and unloading for each pressure.[36,37]
In-situ measurements of the complex impedance of olivine are carried out at 1.0 GPa–4.0 GPa and 573 K–873 K. Figures
where L is the thickness of the sample (in unit m), S is the sample cross-sectional area (in unit m2), and R is the measured resistance (in unit Ω).
At pressures in a range of 1.0 GPa–4.0 GPa and temperatures in range of 573 K–873 K, the relationship between olivine conductivity and reciprocal temperature conforms to the Arrhenius equation:
where σ0 is the pre-exponential factor (in units S/m), ΔH is the activation enthalpy, T is the temperature, and k is the Boltzmann’s constant. The relationship among activation enthalpy (ΔH), activation energy (ΔU; in unit eV), pressure (P; in unit GPa), and activation bulk volume (ΔV; in unit cm3/mol) is
The relationship between electrical conductivity and temperature at 1.0 GPa-4.0 GPa is shown in Fig.
Electrical conductivity increases with temperature increasing (Fig.
where σ is the conductivity, n is the charge carrier concentration, and q is the effective charge. Therefore, an increase in the carrier concentration leads to a higher sample conductivity.
A monotonic linear relationship exists between the logarithm of electrical conductivity and temperature, which suggests that only one olivine conduction mechanism exists at 573 K–873 K. The main mantle minerals (i.e., ferromagnesian silicates) typically have three conduction mechanisms, i.e., protons, small polarons, and ions.[40] Different conduction mechanisms can be distinguished from the activation enthalpy and activation bulk volume.[10,41,42] The activation enthalpy of the proton conduction mechanism in hydrous silicate is typicall y < 1.0 eV and is weakly dependent on temperature. The activation enthalpy and activation bulk volume in our experiments are relatively low (ΔH < 1.0 eV; Table
The conductivities of olivine measured without oxygen fugacity buffering are clearly lower than those measured with buffering (Fig.
where
We compare our olivine conductivity data with the data from previous studies.[18,22,45,46] The data obtained with an oxygen fugacity buffer are in better agreement with previous experiments than with those determined without a buffer (Fig.
We present a novel technique for controlling the oxygen fugacity during DAC experiments, which combines magnetron sputtering and thin film photolithography technologies. Oxygen fugacity buffering rings in a composite insulating gasket composed of Mo and MoO2 form a closed sample chamber that can control the oxygen atmosphere. The Mo and MoO2 on the diamond anvil surface not only provide an oxygen atmosphere for the sample, but also serve as an electrode for measuring the electrical properties of a sample at high temperature and pressure. This new technique solved the problem of the previous lack of oxygen fugacity control in DAC experiments.
We determine the olivine conductivity parameters with our new method at 523 K–873 K and 1.0 GPa–4.0 GPa. With temperature increasing, the electrical conductivity increases, according to the Arrhenius relationship. The measured olivine conductivity parameters indicate that the dominant conduction mechanism is by small polarons. Our results show that the sample oxidation conditions are well buffered by the Mo–MoO2 reaction. This new technique can reduce uncertainties compared with conventional DAC experiments, due to careful consideration of the sample environment, including ensuring temperature homogeneity, correcting sample thickness, and eliminating current leakage by using an insulating gasket. This new method can be used to accurately measure the mineral and rock conductivity in the deep Earth, and can also be applied to other experiments where oxygen fugacity control is desirable.
[1] | |
[2] | |
[3] | |
[4] | |
[5] | |
[6] | |
[7] | |
[8] | |
[9] | |
[10] | |
[11] | |
[12] | |
[13] | |
[14] | |
[15] | |
[16] | |
[17] | |
[18] | |
[19] | |
[20] | |
[21] | |
[22] | |
[23] | |
[24] | |
[25] | |
[26] | |
[27] | |
[28] | |
[29] | |
[30] | |
[31] | |
[32] | |
[33] | |
[34] | |
[35] | |
[36] | |
[37] | |
[38] | |
[39] | |
[40] | |
[41] | |
[42] | |
[43] | |
[44] | |
[45] | |
[46] |